Parabolas from String Art (Part 8)

Recently, I announced that my paper Parabolic Properties from Pieces of String had been published in the magazine Math Horizons. The article had multiple aims; in chronological order of when I first started thinking about them:

Prove that string art from two line segments traces a parabola.
Prove that a quadratic polynomial satisfies the focus-directrix property of a parabola, which is the reverse of the usual logic when students learn conic sections.
Prove the reflective property of parabolas.
Accomplish all of the above without using calculus.

While I’m generally pleased with the final form of the article, the necessity of publication constraints somewhat abbreviated the original goal of this project: determining a pedagogically sound way of convincing a bright Algebra I student that string art unexpectedly produces a parabola. While all the necessary mathematics is in the article, I think the article is somewhat lacking on how to sell the idea to students. So, in this series of posts, I’d like to expand on the article with some pedagogical thoughts about connecting string art to parabolas.

We have shown in the last couple of posts that if the three points that generate the Our explorations of string art led us to consider an arbitrary string $\overline{PQ}$ depicted below. For brevity, this string will be called “string $s$ ,” matching the (possibly non-integer) $x$ -coordinate of its left endpoint $P$ . Since $P$ is $s$ units to the right of $A$ , the right endpoint $Q$ must correspondingly be $s$ units to the right of $B$ . Therefore, the $x$ -coordinate of $Q$ is $s + 8$ .

Previously, we established that the equation for string $s$ is

$y = -\displaystyle \frac{s^2}{4} + \frac{xs}{4} - x + 8$ .

Finding the curve traced by the strings is a two-step process:

For a fixed value of $x$ , find the value of $s$ that maximizes $y$ .
Find this optimal value of $y$ .

Previously, we showed using only algebra that the optimal value of $s$ is $s = \displaystyle \frac{x}{2}$ , corresponding to an optimal value of $y$ of $y = \displaystyle \frac{x^2}{16} - x + 8$ .

For a student who knows calculus, the optimal value of $s$ can be found by instead solving the equation $\displaystyle \frac{dy}{ds} = 0$ (or, more accurately, $\displaystyle \frac{\partial y}{\partial s} = 0$ ):

$\displaystyle \frac{dy}{ds} = -\frac{2s}{4} + \frac{x}{4}$

$0 = \displaystyle \frac{-2s+x}{4}$

$0 = -2s + x$

$2s = x$

$s = \displaystyle \frac{x}{2}$ ,

matching the result that we found by using only algebra.

Parabolas from String Art (Part 7)

Prove that string art from two line segments traces a parabola.
Prove that a quadratic polynomial satisfies the focus-directrix property of a parabola, which is the reverse of the usual logic when students learn conic sections.
Prove the reflective property of parabolas.
Accomplish all of the above without using calculus.

Our explorations of string art led us to consider an arbitrary string $\overline{PQ}$ depicted below. For brevity, this string will be called “string $s$ ,” matching the (possibly non-integer) $x$ -coordinate of its left endpoint $P$ . Since $P$ is $s$ units to the right of $A$ , the right endpoint $Q$ must correspondingly be $s$ units to the right of $B$ . Therefore, the $x$ -coordinate of $Q$ is $s + 8$ .

In the previous post, we established that the equation for string $s$ is

$y = -\displaystyle \frac{s^2}{4} + \frac{xs}{4} - x + 8$

This has the appearance of a quadratic equation, but it’s actually a linear equation in $x$ for a fixed value of $s$ . For example, if s = 5, we find that the equation of string 5 is

$y = -\displaystyle \frac{25}{4} + \frac{5x}{4} - x +8 = 0.25x+1.75$ ,

matching the equation of the blue string we found in a previous post in this series.

To prove that the strings trace a parabola, we now determine which string $s$ maximizes the value of $y = -\displaystyle \frac{1}{4}s^2 + \frac{x}{4}s - x + 8$ for a given value of $x$ . Algebra students can determine this maximum by recalling that a quadratic function $y = as^2 + bs + c$ is maximized (for negative $a$ ) when $s = \displaystyle -\frac{b}{2a}$ . Therefore, the string with largest $y$ -coordinate for a given value of $x$ is

$s = \displaystyle -\frac{x/4}{2 \cdot (-1/4)} = \frac{x}{2}$ .

For example, if $x = 4$ , then string $s = 4 / 2 = 2$ has the largest $y$ -coordinate, matching our previous observations.
To complete the proof that the strings above trace a parabola, we substitute $s = \displaystyle \frac{x}{2}$ into $y = -\displaystyle \frac{s^2}{4} + \frac{xs}{4} - x + 8$ to find the value of this largest $y-$ coordinate:

$y = -\displaystyle \frac{(x/2)^2}{4} + \frac{x(x/2)}{4} - x + 8$

$= -\displaystyle \frac{x^2}{16} + \frac{x^2}{8} - x + 8$

$= \displaystyle \frac{x^2}{16} - x + 8$ ,

matching the result that we found earlier in this series.

There’s also a bonus result. We further note that, for every $x$ , there is only one string $s = \frac{x}{2}$ that intersects the parabola $y = \displaystyle \frac{x^2}{16} - x + 8$ . Since each $x$ is associated with a unique string $s$ and vice versa, we conclude that each string intersects the parabola at exactly one point. In other words, string $s$ is tangent to the parabola $y = \displaystyle \frac{x^2}{16} - x + 8$ when $x=2s$ .

We note that all of the above calculations were entirely elementary, in the sense that calculus was not used and that only techniques from algebra were employed. That said, the word “elementary” in mathematics can be a bit loaded — this means that it is based on simple ideas that are perhaps used in a profound and surprising way. Perhaps my favorite quote along these lines was this understated gem from the book Three Pearls of Number Theory after the conclusion of a very complicated multi-page proof in Chapter 1:

You see how complicated an entirely elementary construction can sometimes be. And yet this is not an extreme case; in the next chapter you will encounter just as elementary a construction which is considerably more complicated.

In the next post, we take a second look at this derivation using techniques from calculus.

Parabolas from String Art (Part 6)

Prove that string art from two line segments traces a parabola.
Prove that a quadratic polynomial satisfies the focus-directrix property of a parabola, which is the reverse of the usual logic when students learn conic sections.
Prove the reflective property of parabolas.
Accomplish all of the above without using calculus.

As discussed previous posts, we begin our explorations with string art connecting evenly spaced points on line segments $\overline{AB}$ and $\overline{BC}$ with endpoints $A(0,8)$ , $B(8,0)$ , and $C(16,8)$ . We will call these colored line segments “strings.” We then found the string with the largest $y-$ coordinate at $x = 2, 4, 6, \dots, 14$ , resulting in the following picture:

In previous posts, we discussed three different ways of establishing that the colored points lie on the parabola $y = \displaystyle \frac{x^2}{16} - x + 8$ .

Unfortunately, checking that a statement is true for a few points (in our case, $x= 0, 2, 4, \dots, 14, 16$ ) does not constitute a complete proof for all points. Furthermore, it’s conceivable that “fuller” string art with additional strings, like the picture below, may identify a new string with a higher $y-$ coordinate than a colored point.

To prove that the string art indeed traces a parabola, we study an arbitrary string $\overline{PQ}$ depicted below. For brevity, this string will be called “string $s$ ,” matching the (possibly non-integer) $x$ -coordinate of its left endpoint $P$ . Since $P$ is $s$ units to the right of $A$ , the right endpoint $Q$ must correspondingly be $s$ units to the right of $B$ . Therefore, the $x$ -coordinate of $Q$ is $s + 8$ .

Since the equations of $\overline{AB}$ and $\overline{BC}$ are $y=-x+8$ and $y=x-8$ , respectively, the $y-$ coordinates of $P$ and $Q$ are $-s+8$ and $(s+8)-8 = s$ , respectively. For example, if $s = 5$ , the coordinates of $P$ are $(s,8-s)=(5,3)$ and the coordinates of $Q$ are $(s + 8, s) = (13, 5)$ , matching the endpoints of the blue string in the first figure.
We now use standard algebraic techniques to find the equation of string $s$ . Its slope is

$m = \displaystyle \frac{ s - (8-s)}{(s+8)-s} = \frac{2s-8}{8} = \frac{s-4}{4}$ .

The coordinates of either $P$ or $Q$ can now be used to find the equation of string $s$ via the point-slope formula. As it turns out, the coordinates of $P$ are simpler to use:

$y-y_1 = m(x-x_1)$

$y-(8-s) = \displaystyle \frac{s-4}{4}(x-s)$

$y = \displaystyle \frac{(s-4)(x-s)}{4} + (8-s)$

$y = \displaystyle \frac{xs-s^2-4x+4s}{4} + 8-s$

$y = \displaystyle \frac{xs}{4} - \frac{s^2}{4} - x + s + 8 - s$

to finally arrive at the equation of string $s$ :

$y = -\displaystyle \frac{s^2}{4} + \frac{xs}{4} - x + 8$

This has the appearance of a quadratic equation, but it’s actually a linear equation in $x$ for a fixed value of $s$ . For example, if s = 5, we find that the equation of string 5 is

$y = -\displaystyle \frac{25}{4} + \frac{5x}{4} - x +8 = 0.25x+1.75$ ,

matching the equation of the blue string we found in a previous post in this series.

We are now almost in position to prove that the string art traces a parabola. We demonstrate this in the next post.

Parabolas from String Art (Part 5)

Prove that string art from two line segments traces a parabola.
Prove that a quadratic polynomial satisfies the focus-directrix property of a parabola, which is the reverse of the usual logic when students learn conic sections.
Prove the reflective property of parabolas.
Accomplish all of the above without using calculus.

However, perhaps it’s clearer to plot these points on a separate graph, without the clutter of the strings:

These points are definitely following some kind of curve. In the previous posts, we established algebraically that the curve is the parabola $y = \displaystyle \frac{x^2}{16} - x + 8$ .

A more modern way of convincing students that the points lie on a parabola is by using technology: specifically, quadratic regression. First, we can input the nine points into a scientific calculator.

Then we ask the calculator to perform quadratic regression on the data.

The calculator then returns the result:

The best quadratic fit to the data is $y = 0.0625x^2 - x + 8$ , or $y = \displaystyle \frac{x^2}{16} - x + 8$ as before. The line $R^2 = 1$ indicates a correlation coefficient of 1, meaning that the points lie perfectly on this parabola. A parenthetical note: If the $R^2$ line does not appear using a TI-83 or TI-84, this can be toggled by using DiagnosticOn:

I’ve presented three different ways that algebra students can convince themselves that the nine points generated by the above string art indeed lie on a parabola. I don’t suggest that all three methods should be used for any given student; as always, if one technique doesn’t appear to work pedagogically, then perhaps a different explanation might work.

However, our explorations aren’t done yet. Any of these three techniques may convince algebra students that the strings above trace a parabola. Unfortunately, checking that a statement is true for a few points (in our case, $x= 0, 2, 4, \dots, 14, 16$ ) does not constitute a complete proof for all points. Furthermore, it’s conceivable that “fuller” string art with additional strings, like the picture below, may identify a new string with a higher $y-$ coordinate than a colored point.

So we have more work to do to prove our assertion that string art traces a parabola. We begin this next phase of our investigations in the next post.