Coin problems

Here’s a problem that a friend posed to me a while ago. Apparently this is called the Coin Problem, but I’d never heard of it before.

McNuggets used to come in boxes of 6, 9, or 20. Given that scheme, what is the largest number of nuggets that cannot be ordered exactly?

Here’s a similar problem:

In American football, teams can score points in increments of 3 (field goal) and 7 (touchdown plus extra point). What is the largest number that can’t be a valid football score? (I’ve ignored other possible ways of scoring — 2-point safeties, 6-point touchdowns without the extra point, 8-point touchdowns with a two-point conversion — because the problem is utterly trivial with these extra options.)

I’m not going to give the answers (if you want to cheat, see the above link), but I suggest questions like these as a way of engaging elementary-school students (who have mastered addition and multiplication) with a non-traditional math question.

On derivatives

This note appeared in the October 2012 issue of the American Mathematical Monthly.

On the news: A very literal pie chart

A very literal pie chart can be seen 20 seconds into this news clip.

Engaging students: The area of a circle

In my capstone class for future secondary math teachers, I ask my students to come up with ideas for engaging their students with different topics in the secondary mathematics curriculum. In other words, the point of the assignment was not to devise a full-blown lesson plan on this topic. Instead, I asked my students to think about three different ways of getting their students interested in the topic in the first place.

I plan to share some of the best of these ideas on this blog (after asking my students’ permission, of course).

This student submission comes from my former student Dale Montgomery. His topic, from Geometry: the area of a circle.

History

Archimedes was the mathematician who we attribute with finding the area of a circle to be Where r is the radius and π is the ratio of circumference to diameter of a circle. (Note that Archimedes was not the first to find the area of a circle, but was the first to find π). I would really like to start the class with something along the lines of introducing Archimedes supposed final words “Do not disturb my circles.” And then go into the death of Archimedes and the mystery surrounding his tomb, such as the account of Cicero and the fact that no one knows where the tomb is now. Cicero said that his tomb had a sphere inscribed in a cylinder, which Archimedes considered to be his greatest mathematical proof. From there, the class should have great interest in what is going on. And we can talk about the fact that the area of a circle is the same as the area a triangle with the same base as the circumference and the same height as the radius.

Rorres, Chris. “Tomb of Archimedes – Illustrations”. Courant Institute of Mathematical Sciences. Retrieved 2011-03-15.

Culture

http://newsfeed.time.com/2013/02/02/are-crop-circles-more-than-just-modern-pranks/

I would show this article in class, most likely passing it out to read. I would ask if they thought it was a prank, and then give them a similar picture as presented in the article but mapped out with radiuses. Then I would say that the average person could do so many square feet of crop’s per hour. If it gets dark at 9 pm and the sun comes up at 6 am, could a person pull a prank like this?

After we discussed how to find the area of a circle I would have found one that it was impossible for one person to do. Then I would display this youtube video.

Seeing that there were 2 people working on it could display that it is possible for it to be a hoax. I like this because it gives the students a way to analyze information that they are given. Does it make sense for these things to be aliens? Not really, so let’s find other explanations. It both introduces the concept and teaches some critical thinking skills.

Applications

You could apply the area of a circle to the diameter of a pizza. When you order pizza you order things like an 8 or a 12 inch. These are diameters and do not give the best idea of how much pizza you are actually getting. You can even include this lesson with a pizza party or something similar. This would easily get kids excited since it is something that most kids like, and they would have the possibility of getting pizza afterwards.

Engaging students: the difference of two squares

I plan to share some of the best of these ideas on this blog (after asking my students’ permission, of course).

This student submission comes from my former student Dale Montgomery. His topic, from Algebra II: the difference of two squares.

Application/Future Curriculum (science)-

You can use difference of squares to find a basic formula to be used in any problem where you drop an object and want to find what time it will take to land. This physics concept will be of interest to your students considering any mechanical science and a useful tool to introduce problem solving by manipulating equations.

Take any height $h$ . If you were to drop an object from this height then it could be modeled with a distance over time graph using the equation

$(h- 9.8/2) t^2$ .

By applying difference of squares you get the expression

$[\sqrt{h}+\sqrt{4.9}] t) \times ( [\sqrt{h} - \sqrt{4.9}] t)$ .

Then by setting this expression equal to 0 and manipulating you would get that
$t = \pm \displaystyle \frac{\sqrt{h}}{\sqrt{4.9}}$ .

I like a situation like this because it allows you to give them linking knowledge about quadratic equations. Most students may not have been exposed to this type of physics yet. However, it is a requirement, and having this knowledge will help them in that class. On top of that it helps with equation manipulation and answering the question, “Does my answer make sense.” This question needs to be asked since it is possible for a student to get an answer of negative time. All of these skills combined with the new topic of difference of squares make for a multifaceted problem. This would probably not be great for day 1 of difference of squares, but I could see it as an engage for the continuance of the lesson.

Curriculum:

You can use the idea of graphing to show that difference of squares works. This is a good way to give visual representation to your students who need it. If you compare the factoring of $x^2-9$ to the graph of $y=x^2-9$ and finding the roots of that graph, you can show that they have the same solutions. It is not that novel, but this visual can just help the idea click into students’ minds.

Manipulative

A manipulative that I got the idea for from http://www.gbbservices.com/math/squarediff.html is using squares to show the difference of squares. This is done quite easily as shown in the picture below. This could be done along a lesson on difference of squares. Maybe this would follow easily from a factoring using algebra tiles. The image below is fairly self explanatory and would really help if made into a hands-on manipulative that kinesthetic learners could make great use of.

Two-Column Proofs that Two-Column Proofs are Terrible

I’m not entirely sure that I completely agree with the author of this post (http://mathwithbaddrawings.com/2013/10/16/two-column-proofs-that-two-column-proofs-are-terrible/), but he certainly provides food for thought and so I’m happy to link to it. Among the most provocative quotes from this post:

In a good proof, each individual step is obvious, but the conclusion is surprising. In many two-column proofs—especially those taught earliest in a geometry course—each individual step is mystifying, while the conclusion is obvious.

From “Reshaping High Schools”

A colleague pointed out the following article to me: Put Understanding First, by Grant Wiggins and Jay McTighe. A sampling:

Unfortunately, the common methods of teaching and testing in high schools focus on acquisition at the expense of meaning and transfer. As a result, when confronted with unfamiliar questions or problems (even selected-response problems on standardized tests), many students flounder. Consider a high school algebra question that was included on state tests in New York and Massachusetts:

To get from his high school to his home, Jamal travels 5.0 miles east and then 4.0 miles north. When Sheila goes to her home from the same high school, she travels 8.0 miles east and 2.0 miles south. What is the measure of the shortest distance, to the nearest tenth of a mile, between Jamal’s home and Sheila’s home? (Students were provided with a grid they could use to plot the answer.)

Fewer than 40 percent of New York 10th graders correctly answered this item, despite the fact that the requisite knowledge is “covered” in every Algebra I class in North America. Test results such as these reveal not a failure of coverage but a failure of transfer.

Out-of-context learning of skills is arguably one of the greatest weaknesses of the secondary curriculum—the natural outgrowth of marching through the textbook instead of teaching with meaning and transfer in mind. Schools too often teach and test mathematics, writing, and world language skills in isolation rather than in the context of authentic demands requiring thoughtful application. If we don’t give students sufficient ongoing opportunities to puzzle over genuine problems, make meaning of their learning, and apply content in various contexts, then long-term retention and effective performance are unlikely, and high schools will have failed to achieve their purpose.

Engaging students: Multiplying and dividing rational expressions

I plan to share some of the best of these ideas on this blog (after asking my students’ permission, of course).

This student submission comes from my former student Kayla (Koenig) Lambert. Her topic, from Pre-Algebra: solving proportions.

B) Curriculum: How does this topic extend what your students have learned in previous courses?

Multiplying and dividing rational expressions extends so many topics because the students have to use what they have learned up to multiplying and dividing the rational expressions. For example, this topic extends multiplying and dividing fractions. For multiplying and dividing fractions the students need to multiply across the numerators and multiply across the denominators and then simplify when possible (Multiplying Rational Expressions). Students also use factoring, which they should have learned before getting to this topic. When factoring, the students should remember different ways to factor. Some different ways are finding the greatest common factor, factoring by grouping, and finding the perfect square. They should also remember how to factor polynomials of different degrees.

The students also need to remember how to divide numerical fractions because they use the same method when dividing rational expressions; multiplying by the reciprocal. Another topic students should have previously learned is how to simplify rational expressions and how to multiply polynomials. Lastly, the students should also remember what a term, coefficient, constant, degree of a term, degree of a polynomial and should remember different types of polynomials (monomial, binomial, etc.). I could keep going with what topics are used when multiplying and dividing rational expressions all the way down to counting, addition, and subtraction. There are obviously so many different topics students have learned in the past that are extended when multiplying and dividing rational expressions.

D) History: What are the contributions of various cultures to this topic?

We can break multiplying and dividing rational expressions into many different mathematical subjects. In order to accomplish multiplying and dividing rational expressions, basic algebra and other basic mathematics had to come first. Methods of multiplication were documented by ancient Egyptian, Greek, and Chinese civilizations (Multiplication-Wikipedia). Around 1800 BC, Egyptians were the first known to use fractions. In 1600 BC, the Babylonians already knew solutions to quadratic equations and also solutions to equations to the third and fourth degree (Mathematics History). Egyptians used papyrus to make papers and used these to “calculate fractions” (Mathematics History).

The word polynomial comes from the Greek work “poly” meaning “many” and from the Latin word “binomium” meaning “binomial” and was introduced in Latin by a French mathematician, Franciscus Vieta (Polynomial-Wikipedia). The history of algebra goes back to ancient Egypt and Babylon where people learned to solve linear and quadratic equations. Also, Islamic mathematicians were able to multiply, divide and find the square root of polynomials. The Hindu-Arabic numerical system was first described by Brahmagupta who gave rules for addition, subtraction, multiplication and division. In orient mathematics, algebra “ultimately evolved from arithmetic” (Mathematics History). Nicole Oresme, from Normandy, was the first person to use fraction and exponents. Many cultures have contributed to multiplying and dividing rational expressions, but I would have to say that the Egyptians, Babylonians, Chinese, and Arabic have contributed the most.

E) Technology: How can technology (YouTube, Geometers Sketchpad, graphing calculator, etc.) be used to efficiently engage students with this topic?

Rational functions are used for many things including:

Fields and forces in physics
Spectroscopy in chemistry
Enzyme kinetics in biochemistry
Electronic circuitry
Aerodynamics
Medicine concentration
Wave functions for atoms and molecules
Optics and photography to improve image resolution
Acoustics and sound

Since the above topics are a little too advanced, I could show the student a video on YouTube to introduce the topic and to show them what multiplying and dividing rational functions are used for in the real world. After this, I would explain to the students that many other careers use rational functions like architects, foresters, and chemists. After talking about the topic, I could them give them a problem like the one below and ask them to graph the rational function with their calculator and can use their calculator to set up tables of values for their rational function. This will make it easy for them to see the maximum and minimum of the function and to see how the function behaves.

Example 9 from PreCalculus:

A rectangular page is designed to contain 48 square inches of print. The margins at the top and bottom of the page are 1 inch deep. The margins on each side are 1 ½ inches wide. What should the dimensions of the page be so the least amount of paper is used?

Works Cited

Larson, Ron, and David C. Falvo. “Precalculus – Ron Larson, David C. Falvo – Google Books.” 7 Feb. 2012. http://books.google.com/books?id=JRzhE6yqeFcC&pg=PA125&dq=what+are+rational+functions+used+for&hl=en&sa=X&ei=1lo1T9zDN-GusQLcrpyuAg&ved=0CFwQ6AEwBQ#v=onepage&q=what%20are%20rational%20functions%20used%20for&f=false.

“Mathematics History.” ThinkQuest : Library. 7 Feb. 2012. http://library.thinkquest.org/22584.

“Multiplication – Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia.” Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. 7 Feb. 2012. <http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiplication>.

“Multiplying Rational Expressions.” Purplemath. 7 Feb. 2012. http://purplemath.com/modules/rtnlmult.htm.

“Polynomial – Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia.” Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. 7 Feb. 2012. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polynomial_Functions#Polynomial_functions.

“Who Created Fractions | Ask Kids Answers.” AskKids Answers | AskKids.com. 7 Feb. 2012. http://answers.askkids.com/Math/who_created_fractions.